Project 2023-02 Analysis and Mitigation of BES Inverter-Based Resource Performance Issues

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ Related Files​

Status

The final ballot for PRC-030-1 Unexpected Inverter-Based Resource Event Mitigation concluded 8 p.m. Eastern, Friday, September 27, 2024​.​ The ballot results can be accessed via the links below. The standard will be submitted to the Board of Trustees for adoption and then filed with the appropriate regulatory authorities.

The Standards Committee approved waivers to the Standards Process Manual at their December 2023 meeting. These waivers were soug​ht to allow for reduced formal comment and ballot periods to assist the drafting team in expediting the process, due to firm timeline expectations set by FERC Order 901. FERC Order 901 was issued under Docket No. RM22-12-000 ​on October 19, 2023

To assist industry in the comment and ballot period, NERC released a Milestone 2 Summary that provides high-level overview of the current state of the associated projects and their interrelationships. The standard drafting team's considerations of the responses received from the previous comment period are reflected in this draft of the standard.​

Background

Multiple NERC disturbance reports,1 including the Odessa disturbance report,2 have identified the undesired performance of bulk power system (BPS)-connected inverter-based resources (IBRs) during grid faults, and have elaborated on the systemic and significant BPS reliability risks that this undesired performance can pose. IBRs may trip for many different reasons, may cease current injection due to inverter controls, or may have unwanted plant-level controller interactions. These types of issues have been extensively documented in the NERC reports. The resulting unexpected and unwarranted loss of generation poses a significant risk to BPS reliability.

Standard Affected: PRC-004-6​

Purpose/Industry Need
This project addresses the reliability‐related need and benefit by requiring analysis and mitigation of unexpected or unwarranted protection and control operations from inverter-based resources following the identification of such a performance issue. This includes any types of protections or controls that result in abnormal performance issues within the plant, including abnormal performance resulting in anomalous behavior of active power output from the facility during events. Considerations may be needed for legacy facilities, but the root cause analysis of the abnormal performance and determination of any mitigating measures should be conducted. The SAR should be applicable to all Bulk Electric System (BES) inverter-based generating resources, including battery energy storage resources.

These changes will prompt analysis of IBR loss events following grid disturbances to ensure that facilities are operating in a reliable manner and providing essential reliability services. Mitigating actions will reduce unnecessary IBR tripping or controls issues that result in widespread reduction of power output from these facilities, and will also reduce the possibility of systemic performance issues in the future.

1 https://www.nerc.com/pa/rrm/ea/Pages/Major-Event-Reports.aspx

2 https://www.nerc.com/pa/rrm/ea/Pages/May-June-2021-Odessa-Disturbance.aspx


Subscribe to this project's observer mailing list
Select "NERC Email Distribution Lists" from the "Service" drop-down menu and specify “Project 2023-02 Analysis and Mitigation of BES Inverter-Based Resource Performance Issues​" in the Description Box.

Draft Actions Dates Results Consideration of Comments
​​Final Ballot

PRC-030-1
Clean | Redline to Last Posted

Implementation Plan
Clean | Redline

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​
Clean​ | Redline

VRF/VSL Ju​s​tifications
Clean | Redline




Final Ballot​​

Info

Vote​





 09/23/24 - 09/27/24



Ballot Results


PRC-030-1

Implementation Plan​

Draft 4

PRC-030-1​

Clean Updated | Redline ​to Last Posted​​ Updated

Implementatio​n Plan​

Clean​ | Redline to Last Posted

 

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​​

Unofficial Comment Form

VRF/VSL Ju​stifications Updated

Mapping Document




​​Additional Ballots

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote




09/04/24 - 09/13/24




Ballot Results

PRC-030-1

Implementation Plan​

Non-binding​ Poll​













Consideration of Comments

​Comment Period 


Info​

Submit Comments​​



0​8/28/24 - 09/13/24​



Comments Received

Draft 3

PRC-030-1​

Clean | Redline ​to Last Posted​​

Implementatio​n Plan​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted

 

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​​

Unofficial Comment Form​

VRF/VSL Ju​stifications​

Mapping Document​


Additional Ballots

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote



08/02/24 - 08/12/24

Ballot Results


PRC-030-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding​ Poll Results​
















Consideration of Comments

​Comment Period 


Info

Submit Comments​​



​07/22/24 - 08/12/24



Comments Received​

Draft 2

PRC-030-1​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​

Implementatio​n Plan​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted

 

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​

Unofficial Comment Form​

VRF/VSL Ju​stifications​​​




Additional Ballots

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote




 07/01/24 - 07/10/24


Ballot Results

 PRC-030-1

 Implementation Plan​

 Non-bindin​g Poll Results​​














Consideration of Comments

​Comment Period 

Info

Submit Comments​​



06/07/24 - 07/10/24



​​
Comments Received​

​Draft 1

PRC-030-1

Implementation Plan​

 

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​

Unofficial Comment Form

VRF/VSL Justifications​​​

Initial Ballot

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote
​​​​​​​​


04/09/24 - 04/18/24

Ballot Results





































Consideration of Comments


Join Ballot Pools

Ballot Pool Reminder​

03/25/24 - 04/03/24
​Comment Period

Inf​o​

Submit Comments​​


0​3/25/24 - 04/18/24


Comments Received​​​
Waiver​​​
Standards Committee accepted the waiver on December 13, 2023.​​​​12/13/2023​
​​Standard Authorization Request
Clean​ | Redline​

Accepted by the Standards Committee


10/18/2023

Drafting Team Nominations

Supporting Materials

 Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)​

Nomination Period

Info

Submit N​om​inations​



02/22/2023 - 03/23/2023




​Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

​Comment Period

Info​​


Submit Comments


0​
2/22/2023 - 03/23/2023​




Consideration of Comments​