Project 2020-02 Modifications to PRC-024 (Generator Ride-through)

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Related Files

Status

Board Adopted: October 8, 2024

Filed with FERC: November 4, 2024


​Background
The Standards Committee accepted the revised SAR and authorized drafting revisions to the Reliability Standards identified in the SAR on April 19, 2023. The objective of the SAR is to modify PRC-024-3 or replace the standard with a performance-based ride-through standard that ensures generators remain connected to the BPS during system disturbances. Specifically, the SAR focuses on using disturbance monitoring data to substantiate IBR ride-through performance during grid disturbances. The SAR also ensures associated generators that fail to ride-through system events are addressed with a corrective action plan (if possible).

​FERC Order 901 requires that IBR-related performance requirements for ride-through are completed and filed with FERC by November 4, 2024. This drafting team will address the IBR-related PRC-029 first and modify PRC-024 to only apply towards synchronous machines. Following the approval of PRC-029, the drafting team will consider additional modifications to PRC-024 to assure performance-based requirements for synchronous machines are adequately addressed per the SAR. 

Standard(s) Affected – ​PRC-024

Purpose/Industry Need
From a risk-based perspective, the goal of the standard is to mitigate the ongoing and systemic performance issues identified across multiple Interconnections and across many disturbances analyzed by NERC and the Regions. Ongoing NERC reports and findings from NERC alerts have continued to substantiate that IBR are failing to ride-through in accordance with expectations and multiple NERC guidelines. These issues have been identified in IBRs as well as synchronous generators, with many causes of tripping entirely unrelated to voltage and frequency protection settings as dictated by the currently effective version of PRC-024.

Subscribe to this project's observer mailing list ​
Select "NERC Email Distribution Lists" from the "Service" drop-down menu and specify “Project 2020-02 Modifications to PRC-024 (Generator Ride-through)​​ Observer List" in the Description Box​.


Draft

Actions

Dates

Results
Consideration of Comments
Errata for Draft 4

PRC-029-1

Implementation Plan






​The Standards Committee approved on October 16, 2024
​​

Final Draft


PRC-024-4

Clean | Re​dline to Last Posted​ | Redline to Last Approved


Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​​​​​​​
PRC-024-4


VRF/VSL Justifications
PRC-024-4​​​


Final Ballot


Info

Vote




09/25/24 - 09/30/24
​Ballot Results

PRC-02​4-4​
​​Draft 4

PRC-029-1
Clean​ | Redline to Last Posted

Implementation Plan

Supporting Materials

NERC and Standards Committee Memo - Summary of Issues and Alternatives Considered *NEW ​

Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

PRC-029-1 Technical Rationale​
Clean | Redline to Last Posted

PRC-029-1 VRF/VSL Justifications
Clean​ | Redline to Last Posted​

Consideration of Directives from FERC Order 901

Additional Ballots and Non-binding Poll


Ballot Reminder​​​

In​fo​

Vote



09/24/24 - 10/04/24 
(extended to allow for review of
NERC/ Standards Committee​ Memo)


Ballot Results


PRC-029-1

 Implementation Plan

Non-​binding Poll​​
​​

Comment Period


Info​

Submit Comments​



09/17/24 - 09/30/24​​



Comments Received
​​Draft 3

PRC-029-1
Clean​ | Redline to Last Posted

Implementation Plan
Clean | Redline to Last Posted

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

PRC-029-1 Technical Rationale
Clean | Redline to Last Posted

PRC-029-1 VRF/VSL Justifications
Clean​ | Redline to Last Posted

Consideration of Directives from FERC Order 901


​Additional Ballots and Non-binding Poll

Ballot Open Reminder

Info

Vote





08/02/24 - 08/12/24

Ballot Results

PRC-029-1

 Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll​
​​​














Consideration of Comments



​Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments​



07/22/24 - 08/12/24
​​


Comments Received​​​
​Draft 2

PRC-024-4

Clean | Redline

PRC-029-1
Clean | Redline

Implementation Plan

Supporting Materials
Unofficial Comment Form (Word)​

Technical Rationales
PRC-024-4​

PRC-029-1
Clean | Redline

VRF/VSL Justifications
PRC-024-4​

PRC-029-1
Clean | Redline


Additional Ballots and Non-binding Polls

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote​





06/28/24 - 07/08/24​
​Ballot Results

PRC-024-4

PRC-029-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results

PRC-024-4

PRC-029-1​



Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments




06/18/24 - 07/08/24




Comments Received​​




​​Draft 1

PRC-024-4
Clean | Redline

PRC-029-1

Implementation Plan​

Supporting Materials
​​Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

Technical Rationales
PRC-024-4

PRC-029-1

VRF/VSL Justifications
PRC-024-4​

PRC-029-1

Initial Ballots and Non-binding Polls

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote



04/12/24 - 04/22/24​
​Ballot Results

PRC-024-4

PRC-029-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results

PRC-024-4

PRC-029-1​


​Join Ballot Pools


03/27​/24 - 04/05/24​



​Comment Period


Info

Submit Comments


03/27/24 - 04/22/24


Comments Received​


​​Waiver
​The Standards Committee approved the waiver on December 13, 2023

PRC-024 Standard Authorization Request
Clean | Redline​


The Standards Committee accepted the SAR on ​April 19, 2023

PRC-024 ​Standard Authorization Request

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

​Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments


05/31/22 - 07/14/22
​​​

Comment​s Received​




Drafting Team Nominations

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)​
Nomination Period

Info

Submit Nominations​


05/31/22 - 07/14/22

​​​​Standard Authorization Request
Clean | Redline

The Standards Committee accepted the SAR on ​April 20, 2022

Supplemental Drafting Team Nominations

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)​


Nomination Period

Info

Submit Nominations



11/19/21 - 12/20/21​

Supplemental Drafting Team Nominations

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)​


Nomination Period

Info​

Submit Nominations



​04/28/21 - 05/17/21


Standard Authorization Request

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form (Word) 

Transmission-connected Dynamic Reactive Resources White Paper



Comment Period

Info
(Updated)

Submit Comments




03/30/20 -
05/13/20(Extended)

 

 

Comments Received



​Consideration of Comments​




Drafting Team Nominations

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)


Nomination Period

Info
(Updated)

Submit Nominations



03/30/20 - 05/13/20(Extended)

 

 ​​​