Project 2022-03 Energy Assurance with Energy-Constrained Resources

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Related Files​

Status
The final ballots for BAL-007-1 Near-term Energy Reliability Assessments, TOP-003-7 Transmission Operator and Balancing Authority Data and Information Specification and Collection, and their implementation plans concluded 8 p.m. Eastern, Wednesday, December 4, 2024. The voting results can be accessed via the links below. The standards will be submitted to the Board of Trustees for adoption and then filed with the appropriate regulatory authorities.

Background

Project 2022-03 currently is addressing the operations/operational planning time horizon Standard Authorization Requests (SARs) that seek to enhance reliability by requiring entities to perform Energy Reliability Assessments (ERAs) to evaluate energy assurance and develop Corrective Action Plan(s), Operating Plan(s), or other mitigating actions to address identified risks to each respective time horizon.

The Standards Committee (SC) accepted the revised SAR at its January 25, 2023, meeting. At the same meeting, the SC authorized drafting of the Reliability Standard(s) identified in the SAR. Since that time, the team has conducted several meetings, both remote and in-person, and posted a draft of a new standard for informal comment to solicit feedback and completed one initial comment and ballot period for BAL-007-1. ​​

Standard(s) Affected: TPL-001-5.1, EOP, TOP, and BAL

Purpose/Industry Need
This project will enhance reliability by requiring entities to perform energy reliability assessments to evaluate energy assurance and develop Corrective Action Plan(s) to address identified risks. Energy reliability assessments evaluate energy assurance across the Operations Planning, Near-Term Transmission Planning, and Long-Term Transmission Planning or equivalent time horizons by analyzing the expected resource mix availability (flexibility) and the expected availability of fuel during the study period.

1Energy_Assurance_White_Paper (nerc.com)


DraftActionsDatesResults​Consideration of Comments

Final Ballot​​s

TOP-003-7

Clean | Redline​ to Last Posted

BAL-007-1​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​

Implementation Plan

 for BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7 

Clea​n | ​Redline to Last Posted​​

​​

Supporting Materials


Technical Rationale

BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7

VRF/VSL ​Justifications

BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7

Definitions

Energy Reliablity Assessment

Near-Term Energy Reliablity Assessment







Final Ballots​​


In​fo​

Vote​







11/25/24 - 12/04/24





Ballot Results


TOP-​003-7

Implementation Plan

BAL-007-1

Implementation Plan

Draft 1

TOP-003-7

Clean | Redline​ to Last Approved

Draft 3

BAL-007-1​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​


Implementation Plan​ for BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7 

Clea​n | Redline to Last Posted​​​​

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Commen​t Form (Word)

Technical Rationale

BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7

VRF/VSL ​Justifications

BAL-007-1 and TOP-003-7






Initial Ballots and Non-binding Poll

TOP-003-7

Additional Ballots and Non-binding Poll
BAL-007-1

Ballot Open Reminder​

Info

Vote​






10/25/24 - 11/04/24



Ballot Results


TOP-003-7

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results

BAL-007-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results​​

























Consideration of Comments


Join Ballot Pools​
for TOP-003-7



09/19/24 - 10/18/24


Comment Period

Info​


Submit Comments​​


​09/19/24 - 11/04/24


Comments Received

Draft 1

BAL-008-1​

Implementation Plan​

Draft 2

BAL-007-1​

Clean | Redline to Last Posted​​

Implementation Plan​


Supporting Materials

Unofficial Commen​t Form (Word)

Technical Rationales

BAL-007-1

BAL-008-1​

VRF/VSL ​Justifications​

BAL-007-1

BAL-008-1​


Initial Ballots and Non-binding Poll
BAL-008-1

Additional Ballots and Non-binding Poll
BAL-007-1

Updated Info​ (Ballot Reminder​)

Upda​ted Info (Extension)
Info

Vote​







06/11/24 - 06/24/24​
(extended to reach quorum)


Ballot Results

BAL-008-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results

BAL-007-1

Implementation Plan

Non-binding Poll Results​





















Consideration of Comments
Join Ballot Pools
05/07/24 - 06/05/24

Comment Period

Updat​ed Info​​ (Extension)

Info


Submit Comments​​


05/7/24 - 06/24/24
(extended)



Comments Received​

Draft 1

BAL-007-1​

Implementation Plan​

 

Supporting Materials

Technical Rationale​

Unofficial Comment Form​

VRF/VSL Justifications​


    


Initial Ballot 

Ballot Open Reminder

Info

Vote




03/01/2024 - 03/11/2024

















Consideration of Comments​
Join Ballot Pools
01/25/2024 - 02/23/2024
​Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments​​


​01/25/2024 - 03/11/2024​


Comment​s Received​​

Supporting Materials



Comment Period

In​fo Updated

Submit Comments​​



09/13/2023 - 10/05/2023​​​



Comments Received​

   Operations and Operations Planning Time Horizons SAR

Clean​ | Redline

 Planning Time Horizons SAR

Clean | Redline



 The Standards Committee accepted these SARs on
January 25, 2023
​​



Drafting Team Nominations

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word) 



Nomination ​​Period

Info​

Submit Nominations​​




06/22/2022 – 07/21/2022

Operations and Operations Planning Time Horizons SAR

Planning Time Horizons SAR


Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form (Word)

ERATF Technical Justification




Comment Period

Info​

Submit Comments​



06/22/2022 – 07/21/2022​




Comments Received​




Consideration of Comments​
 

​